ERP Selection

Selecting the Right ERP Is One of the Most Important Business Decisions You'll Make

Independent ERP selection guidance for organizations that need to choose with confidence — not based on a sales deck. We help you define what matters, evaluate honestly, and align leadership before contracts are signed.

Most ERP selection processes are quietly driven by the loudest vendor in the room. PRH Consulting brings independent, senior practitioners who have implemented ERP on the inside and know exactly where projects later go wrong. Our job is to make sure your selection process is grounded in your business requirements — not in a software demo cycle.

We work with executive teams, IT leadership, and finance to build a structured selection process that produces a defensible decision. Whether your shortlist includes Sage X3, NetSuite, SAP, Acumatica, Microsoft Dynamics, JD Edwards, Epicor, or industry-specific platforms, our analysis stays focused on fit, total cost of ownership, implementation risk, and long-term scalability.

Our consultants have advised manufacturers, distributors, food & beverage organizations, and multi-entity groups across the United States and the Caribbean. We bring the same discipline to every selection: define real requirements, evaluate honestly, and protect the client from making a multi-million-dollar decision on incomplete information.

Who this is for

  • Companies replacing QuickBooks or a legacy ERP
  • Organizations consolidating multiple systems onto one platform
  • Multi-company groups standardizing across entities and geographies
  • Manufacturers and distributors that need real industry fit
  • Boards and PE sponsors funding a major ERP investment
  • Executive teams who want a second opinion on an in-flight selection

What we deliver

ERP Readiness Assessment

Honest evaluation of organizational, process, data, and technology readiness before evaluation begins.

Requirements Definition

Functional, technical, integration, and reporting requirements documented in vendor-neutral language.

Vendor Long-List & Short-List

Market scan, prequalification, and a defensible shortlist tied directly to your business priorities.

RFP Authoring & Management

Structured RFP, scoring rubric, vendor Q&A management, and proposal normalization for apples-to-apples comparison.

Demo Scripting & Scoring

Scenario-based demo scripts tied to your real processes, plus standardized scoring across stakeholders.

Total Cost of Ownership Modeling

5-year TCO comparison across license, implementation, infrastructure, integrations, support, and internal effort.

Implementation Partner Evaluation

The software is half the decision. We evaluate the partner methodology, team, and references.

Executive Alignment & Contract Review

Working sessions with C-suite and the board, plus an independent review of statements of work and contracts.

Our approach

Anchor on the business, not the software

We start with strategy, growth plans, and operational pain — then translate into selection criteria.

Run a structured, defensible process

Every step is documented so the eventual recommendation can withstand boardroom and audit-committee scrutiny.

Pressure-test the demo cycle

Vendor demos follow our scripts and your scenarios, not a polished sales reel.

Stay independent

We are not paid by software vendors. The recommendation is the one your evidence supports.

Outcomes you can expect

  • A documented ERP decision built on real business requirements
  • Comparable, normalized proposals across vendors and implementation partners
  • Realistic TCO and timeline expectations agreed by leadership
  • Reduced risk of post-go-live regret and replacement projects
  • Executive and board alignment before the contract is signed

Related services

Make your ERP selection with senior, independent guidance

An ERP selection done well protects years of capital and operational performance. Talk to us early — even before vendors are in the room.

Schedule a Consultation